.svg)
Talk With An Expert
(615) 649-5002
Exposed‑fastener metal roofs succeed or fail at the screw. A typical Classic Panel roof in Nashville contains thousands of fasteners; each one is a potential leak path if the screw type is mismatched to the job or driven incorrectly. Water only needs a tiny gap around a washer to follow wind pressure and capillary action into the assembly. Over time, thermal expansion and contraction work those gaps wider if the screw and washer can’t flex and recover. This article explains, without vendor hype, why traditional “barn screws” struggle in Middle Tennessee’s climate, how ZAC‑type long‑life fasteners with EPDM washers improve durability, and what correct installation looks like so a homeowner, GC, or crew leader can evaluate work with confidence and avoid repeat maintenance.
“Barn screw” is a common name for economy exterior screws with painted carbon‑steel heads and basic neoprene washers. They’re inexpensive and available everywhere, which is why many DIY installs use them. The problem is their weak points show up quickly outdoors. Painted heads chip from tool contact and ladder rub, then chalk under UV and form red rust that can streak onto the panel. Neoprene washers start flexible but dry out, flatten, and crack as UV, ozone, and heat attack the rubber. As wood decks breathe with humidity and temperature, marginally driven screws can back out a fraction of a turn, loosening the seal just enough for driven rain to enter. On hot days, thin washers cold‑flow; on cold mornings, they can’t rebound, so micro‑gaps open and close with every cycle. None of these issues are dramatic on day one, but after a few seasons in Nashville’s sun and storms, the pattern is obvious: rusty heads, halo staining, and damp sheathing around the worst fasteners.
ZAC‑type fasteners use a zinc–aluminum alloy cupped head that resists red rust and shades the sealing washer from direct sunlight. The cup also helps center torque on the washer so compression is even. Their EPDM washers are engineered to remain elastic under UV, heat, and ozone, so they maintain a tight seal as panels expand and contract through seasons. EPDM also resists the “set” that cheaper washers take, meaning it bounces back instead of staying flattened. Shanks and points are matched to the substrate, self‑drilling points for steel purlins reduce burrs and heat, while deep hi‑lo threads bite predictably into plywood or dimensional lumber. Combined, these features aim for a fastener that lasts like the panel: the head doesn’t become a rust source, and the gasket continues to seal after thousands of temperature cycles and years of sun.
A reliable field check is simple: tighten until the EPDM washer spreads to the edge of the metal cap. That indicates full contact without over‑compression. If the washer still turns under a fingertip, the screw is under‑driven and not sealing; give it another quarter turn. If the washer mushrooms beyond the cap or splits, it’s over‑driven; the gasket is damaged and will age faster. Temperature affects feel, on very hot days washers feel softer, so sneak up on torque with test screws in scrap. On cold mornings they feel stiffer and it’s easy to under‑drive. Consistency matters more than speed; crews that pause to check the first dozen fasteners each morning avoid hours of callbacks later.
Screws driven at an angle deform the seal and create a path for water along the high side of the washer. Keep the driver perpendicular to the panel by bracing your wrist, using two hands when possible, and choosing a bit length that lets the tool stay square without hitting the rib. Start the screw slowly so the point centers; then maintain light, steady pressure. If a screw starts to wander or visibly leans, stop, back it out, and re‑drive it straight into sound material. Do not rely on sealant to compensate, sealants weather faster than a proper gasket and mask rather than solve the error.
Use a screw gun with depth/torque control instead of a drill or impact driver. Impacts are convenient but they deliver hammering torque that routinely over‑drives and chews washers. Drills can work in expert hands, but feathering a trigger to the same torque thousands of times is unrealistic. A screw gun lets you set the clutch and repeat results. Typical speeds are around 2,500 RPM for wood and thin steel, about 2,000 RPM for thicker steel, and 1,000–2,000 RPM for 304 stainless screws that gall if spun too fast. Use a magnetized hex driver that matches the head snugly to avoid cam‑out scars that become rust starters. Before starting a run, test on offcuts to tune clutch and speed; then keep that setting until conditions change.
Layout is performance and curb appeal at the same time. Snap chalk lines so rows land precisely on purlins or in the center of solid decking and so edge zones get the tighter spacing most engineering sheets require at eaves, ridges, and gables. Straight rows also reduce panel distortion because loads transfer evenly. Use blue or white chalk, red can stain light colors, and wipe lines off with a soft rag after fastening. Don’t rely on rain; chalk binds to textured finishes and leaves ghosts. When walking panels to place screws, step where the profile is strongest (ribs or over framing) to limit panel flex that could change how washers seat. Follow the manufacturer pattern for edges, side laps, and end laps rather than eyeballing it; those patterns are tied to tested wind pressures and capillary paths.
Cutting and drilling create swarf, tiny steel fragments that oxidize quickly, especially after a summer shower. Even stainless shavings can discolor finishes as they corrode. Brush panels with a soft‑bristle broom the same day you drill or cut; a magnetic sweeper helps along eaves, gutters, and staging areas. Avoid abrasive cutoff wheels that throw hot, fused grit onto finishes; prefer shears, nibblers, or cold‑cut saws that make cooler chips. Lay down tarps below cut areas to catch debris, and empty gutters of swarf before leaving; downspouts concentrate rust stains that are almost impossible to erase later.
Modern roofing screws are self‑drilling, so many installs proceed without pre‑drilling. Still, over a solid wood deck, pre‑drilling straight rows can keep long screws plumb, give perfectly even spacing, and even save time when crews stack, clamp, and drill bundles at measured intervals. Use a bit only slightly smaller than the screw’s root diameter so threads engage firmly without splitting the wood. Keep holes perpendicular; oval or angled pilots make seating inconsistent. Over metal purlins, pre‑drilling is risky because holes must align with supports exactly; drilling as you go lets you correct for minor framing variation and ensures each fastener bites full‑thickness steel, not the edge of a flange.
Use metal‑to‑wood screws with deep hi‑lo threads for plywood and dimensional lumber; choose length so at least an inch of thread engages solid wood without piercing far beyond. Use metal‑to‑metal self‑drillers for steel framing or retrofits over existing metal; pick the correct drill‑point style for the thickness you’re penetrating to avoid burned points and oversize holes. At side and end laps, use designated lap screws with sealing washers and, where specified, butyl tape to block capillary action; stitching screws without washers belong in certain overlap locations only and should never substitute for gasketed fasteners in the field. Edge zones often call for closer spacing than the field because uplift loads are highest there; follow the engineering for the exact profile you’re installing rather than copying a pattern from a different panel.
Middle Tennessee roofs see fast‑moving thunderstorms, sharp gust fronts, spring hail, heavy pollen in April–May, and very warm summers. UV light accelerates chalking of painted heads and aging of cheap washers; sudden pressure changes during storms test every marginal seal. On 3:12 and steeper roofs with straightforward geometry, combining corrosion‑resistant heads, UV‑stable EPDM washers, correct torque, straight driving, disciplined layout, and same‑day cleanup produces a tighter roof that needs less attention year after year. Those choices are why two exposed‑fastener roofs of similar age can look and perform so differently on the same street.
Plan a simple spring and fall inspection. Rinse dust and pollen with low‑pressure water, clear gutters and valleys, and scan for tilted screws, flattened or cracked washers, rusty heads, and any screws that have backed out. Re‑seat or replace outliers promptly; the first few that fail usually appear at edges and laps where loads are highest. Damp spots that appear only during sideways rain often trace to side‑lap gaps or missing lap screws, close the seam and add the correct fasteners rather than sealing the interior stain. Orange speckles on panels are swarf stains; they won’t wash off easily and underscore the importance of same‑day cleanup. When walking the roof for any reason, wear soft‑soled shoes, step on ribs or over framing, and avoid hot afternoons when warm finishes scuff more easily.
The screw is the smallest part of a metal roof and the most common source of avoidable leaks. Selecting corrosion‑resistant, long‑life fasteners with EPDM washers, and installing them at the right torque, angle, spacing, and sequence while removing swarf and using appropriate tools, creates a resilient exposed‑fastener roof for Middle Tennessee. The benefits do not announce themselves on day one. They show up in year five, year ten, and after the first big wind‑driven storm when the roof stays quiet and dry.
.png)
