Roof Type Comparison

Metal Roof vs Asphalt Shingle:  Which is the Better Choice?

Metal and asphalt roofing are two of the most popular options for residential and commercial properties, but they differ significantly in durability, performance, and long-term value.

A metal roof lasts decades longer than asphalt, providing superior protection against extreme weather and reducing maintenance costs. While the initial investment is higher, homeowners who choose metal roofing benefit from energy efficiency, lower insurance premiums, and fewer replacements—making ita smarter long-term investment.

In contrast, asphalt shingles offer a lower upfront cost and are widely available, but they require replacement every 10 to 15 years. They also provide less resistance to wind and hail and have limited color and style options. While asphalt remains a practical solution for short-term budgets, homeowners who prioritize longevity and aesthetics often find metal roofing offers a higher return on investment.

Metal Roofs Compared To Traditional Roofs

Scroll to the right to compare roof types!

Composite Roof

15 - 30 years
1 - 2 weeks
10 - 20 years
15 - 30 years
1 - 2 weeks
10 - 20 years
Average Lifetime of the Roof:
The Metal Roofers Warranty:
Non-Prorated Warranty:
Length of Roof Install Process:
Wind Rating
Ventilation Integration
Environmental Impact
Fire Resistance
Energy Efficiency
Solar Panel Compatibility
Snow Shedding
Maintenance Needs
Insurance Discounts
Pest Resistance
Hail Resistance
Mold & Algae Growth
Noise
Insurance Premiums
Lightning Conductivity

Metal Roof

Lifetime
Lifetime
Yes
A few days to a week
180+ mph
Intergrated
Recyclable
Class A (highest fire rating)
Lowers cooling costs
Ideal for mounting; no re-roofing needed
Sheds snow naturally
Minimal
Often qualifies
Impervious
Rated for severe hail
Inhibits mildew,
Sound-dampening underlayments
May qualify
Does not attract

Asphalt Roof

10 - 15 years
15 - 30 years*
No
A few days to a week
60 - 100 mph
More prone to heat
Can leach chemicals into groundwater
May melt or ignite under extreme heat
Absorbs heat
Re-roofing before solar install
Snow buildup common
Regular inspections,
Standard risk rating
Can harbor
Susceptible
Organic growth
Naturally quieter
Standard premiums
Same strike risk

Composite Roof

15 - 30 years
1 - 2 weeks
10 - 20 years
15 - 30 years
1 - 2 weeks
10 - 20 years

Savings Calculator

Metal vs. Shingle Roof Savings Over the Lifetime

Type in the square footage of your roof to see how much you could be saving!
Calculate
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Total Lifetime Savings

$0
Low
$0
High
15-30%
Home Insurance Premium Savings
10-20%
Energy Savings
DISCLAIMER: This is not a guarantee on pricing or savings, but gives general range of savings. The Metal Roofers cannot give an accurate price or savings expectation without first seeing the home due to factors such as roof design, multiple stories, type of metal roofing, and more. Likewise, insurance companies vary in their premium reductions for metal roofs and energy savings depend on numerous variables.
Call Today!
(615) 649-5002
Roof

Don't Settle For Less Than Metal

Schedule Your Free Quote Today!

Schedule Your Free Quote